Book a free call

I read 58 local marketing websites. 18 promise what nobody can keep.

I read the websites of 58 marketing and SEO companies selling to Lower Mainland businesses. What they promise, what they charge, and what Google says about guarantees.

One dot for each marketing website

One dot per local marketing website. Red promise the top of Google or guarantee results; orange promise you’ll “dominate” or “skyrocket”; lime say plainly that nobody can guarantee rankings.

The short answer

18 of the 58 promise something nobody can keep, like the top of Google, guaranteed results, or that you’ll “dominate” or “skyrocket”. Only 5 say plainly that nobody can guarantee rankings. Google’s own guide to hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.

Before I wrote my own marketing page, I wanted to know what local business owners are being promised. So I read the websites of 66 marketing and SEO companies that sell to Lower Mainland businesses. 58 of them loaded.

#1
ranking on Google is something no one can guarantee, says Google itself Google Search Central

What they promise

I counted only promises made to you, the business owner. Not case studies, not reviews.

  • 8 promise the top of Google, or guarantee results.
  • 10 promise you’ll “dominate”, “skyrocket” or grow 10x.
  • 5 say plainly that nobody can guarantee rankings.
  • 35 promise none of these.

That’s 18 of 58 making a promise nobody can keep. 3 of the 5 guarantees come with a refund or free work if it doesn’t happen.

Some of the phrases, word for word:

  • “Making you #1”
  • “Page One Results”
  • “Rank #1 to #3 on search engines”
  • “Guaranteed increase in traffic, leads and rankings”
  • “Grow 10x faster”
  • “Dominate page one”
  • “Skyrocket your rankings”
  • “Be at the top of Google search and ChatGPT”

What Google says

Google decides who shows up, and it changes its mind. In its own guide to hiring an SEO, Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. A promise like that is a sales line, not a plan.

Want a second opinion on yours? My free Site Check looks at your website and your Google listing. Good news first.

Get my free Site Check

What they charge

I found a monthly SEO price on 10 of the 58 websites. Here’s the cheapest plan on each, highest first.

PlanWhereA month
SEO, conversion and speedVancouverUS$4,000
SEO and AI searchVancouver$2,500
SEO starterLangley$2,500
SEO and AI searchSurrey$1,500
SEO programVancouver$995
Local SEOLangley$950
Local SEOAbbotsford$800
SEO, basic planLangley$750
Local SEOPort Coquitlam$695
Local SEOVancouver$500

On their Clutch listings, 29 of the 42 agencies that list a rate charge $100 an hour or more, and 20 of 44 want $5,000 or more before they start. Agencies include different work at different prices, so compare what’s done each month, not just the number.

How I did it

I read the websites of 66 marketing and SEO companies selling to Lower Mainland businesses: those in Clutch’s Lower Mainland SEO listings, and those that came up when I searched “SEO company” in ten Lower Mainland cities. 58 loaded. Monthly prices are each company’s lowest SEO plan on its own website; hourly rates and minimum projects come from each one’s Clutch listing. November 2026. No names here: this is about the promises, not the people.

See how I do marketing, for $199 a month, all in.

Key takeaways

  • 18 of 58 Lower Mainland marketing websites promise the top of Google, guaranteed results, or that you’ll “dominate” or “skyrocket”.
  • Only 5 of the 58 say plainly that nobody can guarantee rankings.
  • Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, in its own guide to hiring an SEO.
  • The cheapest monthly SEO plan on their own websites was $500, and the dearest was US$4,000.

Sources

  1. Google Search CentralDo you need an SEO?

More from
the studio.

See what your
website is missing.

Your free Site Check: 120 checks, in your inbox in minutes.

or

I look forward to talking with you.